Mimesis Law
1 April 2020

James Blake Gets The Bum’s Rush, Twice

Sept. 10, 2015 (Mimesis Law) — The guy was a tennis star, ranked fourth in the world with a very high USTA rating, before he retired. James Blake was the real thing, accomplishing fame through sweat and effort. That’s no small feat. Not that it did him a lot of good in the Big Apple.

Retired black tennis star James Blake, in an NYPD double-fault, was slammed to a Manhattan sidewalk and handcuffed by a white cop in a brutal case of mistaken identity.

The 35-year-old Blake, once ranked No. 4 in the world, suffered a cut to his left elbow and bruises to his left leg as five plainclothes cops eventually held him for 15 minutes Wednesday outside the Grand Hyatt Hotel.

It seems some cell-phone delivery snitch fingered Blake as a guy to whom some phones were delivered the day before as part of a credit card fraud investigation, and New York’s Finest needed to take him out. So a guy in plainclothes, shorts no less, charged at Blake.

The unidentified officer picked Blake up, threw the 6-foot-1 player down on the sidewalk and commanded him to roll over facedown.

Because those credit card fraudsters can be killers, you know, and why should a cop risk his life by walking up to a guy standing there, doing nothing, minding his own business, and tell him that he’s being arrested? Why when you can just throw him to the concrete?

As he started texting on his phone, Blake looked up and saw someone in shorts and a T-shirt racing at him.

“Maybe I’m naïve, but I just assumed it was someone I went to high school with or someone who was running at me to give me a big hug, so I smiled at the guy,” Blake said.

At least, that’s what James Blake says happened. The police story remains sketchy at the moment.

Mr. Bratton, in the NY1 interview, said: “We will very aggressively address it. I will not tolerate any type of excessive use of force on the part of my police.

It’s always soothing to learn that New York Police Commissioner Bill Bratton won’t tolerate excessive force, when the target is a famous person, the world is watching and there’s likely video. And yet,

But as always, and we have that saying, ‘The first story is never the last story,’ so we’ll wait and see what we get for facts and circumstances and, hopefully, video.”

Never has a police commissioner spoken truer words than “the first story is never the last story,” as James Blake’s description, the eyewitnesses’ description, of how the plainclothes cop gave Blake the bum’s rush, not bothering to announce that he was a cop, and slamming him to the sidewalk “in an excess of caution,” clearly is a one-sided point of view.

The cops, as Bratton well knows, need time, some breathing room, to reflect deeply on their conduct so they can come up with a plausible story that will explain why it was necessary to use force to save the children. Or something like that.

Even if they can’t come up with an actual excuse for this “irrational exuberance,” at least they can minimize the appearance of taking down another black guy who happened to have once been fourth in the world in tennis.

Do the police, who risk their lives arresting credit card fraudsters and tennis stars, making split-second decisions, not deserve the public’s acquiescence to withholding judgment until they get a chance to make up a story? Don’t police lives matter too?

Blake notes that the officer who gave him the bum’s rush failed to apologize for his error, even after a retired officer informed him that he just slammed a huge tennis star to the concrete. But nobody, per the press conference, told Bill Bratton that his implication that James Blake, tennis star, was lying about what happened because he’s got such a strong motive to make stuff up and smear the NYPD, was a second bum’s rush. And Bratton also didn’t apologize for suggesting that Blake was a liar.

6 Comments on this post.

Leave a Reply



Comments for Fault Lines posts are closed here. You can leave comments for this post at the new site, faultlines.us

  • Ken Womble
    10 September 2015 at 10:23 am - Reply

    Even if they got the right guy (they did not), how is it OK to tackle someone suspected of the most non-violent of crimes? There was no allegation of a weapon (yet – give them time to “investigate”). One thing is for certain. If they had tackled the right guy (they did not), that person would be charged with resisting arrest as well. Maybe even assaulting the officers if he happened to jam his face into their fists.

    • shg
      10 September 2015 at 10:33 am - Reply

      Are you denying that credit-card fraudsters are violent criminals, who would charge at the drop of a hat? The First Rule of Policing, bro. Do you want a cop with overdrafts on your conscience?

    • Mark Draughn
      10 September 2015 at 11:16 am - Reply

      “Mumble mumble aggressive stance mumble mumble mumble furtive move mumble mumble split-second decision mumble mumble mumble policy…”

  • losingtrader
    10 September 2015 at 3:03 pm - Reply

    Everyone knows the “bum rush” was better than shooting 9 innocent bystanders. If the cops would just bum rush all suspects, I’d feel a lot safer…and I don’t live in NYC

  • James Blake and His Evil Innocent Twin | Simple Justice
    12 September 2015 at 8:57 am - Reply

    […] have questioned what the big deal is with a NYPD detective’s take down of tennis star James Blake.  Now that the video has been released, two points are raised by those […]

  • When Public Relations Fails | Simple Justice
    16 September 2015 at 7:04 am - Reply

    […] the usual tropes used by cops to justify why no one but a cop can criticize a cop. He responds to the criticism of Officer James Frascatore for leaping to violence to take out tennis great James […]